Seafood markets

Reynolds Seafood

4.7 743 reviews Closed 336 N Herritage St, Kinston, NC 28501, United States

Discover this place

Reynolds Seafood, located at 336 N Herritage St, Kinston, NC, has become a cherished seafood market for locals and visitors alike. With a legacy that spans generations, customers like Deidra fondly recall their childhood experiences, returning to create new memories with their families. The exceptional service at Reynolds is a recurring theme, with patrons describing the staff as patient and accommodating, particularly in heartfelt situations, as noted by Belinda, who appreciates their kindness towards her uncle battling dementia.

The freshness of the seafood is undoubtedly the highlight here. Customers rave about the quality of fish, shrimp, and clams, often stating they no longer shop anywhere else for their seafood needs. Jaime sums it up perfectly, declaring Reynolds the go-to spot for local seafood sourced directly from the sea. With a variety of seasonings available, they ensure every meal is deliciously customized. From the warm, welcoming atmosphere to the outstanding product offerings, Reynolds Seafood is not just a market; it's a community hub where hospitality meets the ocean's bounty.

For seafood lovers, this quintessential gem deserves a visit. You might just find your new favorite dish here!

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Onsite services
Delivery

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Reynolds Seafood before visiting.

Reviews for Reynolds Seafood

4.7

743 reviews

100%

15%

Review highlights

Based on 743 reviews

Reynolds Seafood is widely praised for its fresh, high-quality seafood and extensive selection that appeals to both longtime locals and returning visitors. Customers consistently highlight the exceptional customer service, noting the staff’s patience, kindness, and attentiveness, which creates a welcoming shopping experience for all ages and needs. The market’s reputation for offering locally sourced seafood and complementary seasonings enhances its appeal. Many reviewers mention a strong sense of tradition and community connection, with families passing down their loyalty across generations. Overall, Reynolds Seafood is recognized as a reliable destination for fresh seafood combined with friendly, personalized service.

Deidra

Jul 17, 2025

I've been coming here since I was a little girl. I loved when my folks would shop here because I could see all the cool looking fish! As an adult, it feels great to continue to share a piece of my childhood with my very own family! They still have amazing customer service and a huge selection. I don't live close by anymore. But when I'm in the area, I have to stop right on in.

Belinda Dixon-Dawson

Jul 07, 2025

I love this place so much because of their GREAT/AWESOME staff members. My uncle is battling DEMENTIA and when we go to Reynolds Seafood he sometimes gets a little confused on what he wants but the staff is always so PATIENT with him. Let me tell you... REYNOLDS SEAFOOD has the BEST fish around and because of that I travel from Ahoskie NC to Ayden NC (every Tuesday) to pick my uncle and mother up and then on to Kinston, NC. to Reynolds Seafood for some FRESH, FRESH, FRESH FISH! Thank you guys soooooooo much for your hospitality! See you on Tuesday!

Jaime

Jun 10, 2025

Always the place to shop for your local seafood choices! Used to try other places for seafood until we found Reynolds, a great local business with fresh and local seafood fresh from the sea. They also offer a variety of seasonings and things to go with your fresh catch. Always support and always satisfied! Recommend!

Christine Torres

Jun 06, 2025

Great fish shrimp clams just all around great fresh yummyyyy I really like it, I only buy sea food from this place great great place and customer service

Damaris Salazar

May 20, 2025

I was technically born there because when my two brothers were born and little we went to this same place to buy seafood. I really recommend this place, they treat people so kind

Dominic Hunter

May 17, 2025

Excellent quality. We got 1st fish nuggets and whiting. The customer service was amazing they made you feel like you were family while your waiting

gwen cradle

Apr 19, 2025

Staff very friendly and knowledgeable. Made me feel at ease about the questions I asked. There are Lots of different type Fish. Lol. Top of my list when I return.